Categories

  • All Discussions
  • Hottest Topics
  • My Discussions
  • Specific Beers
  • Specific Brewers
  • General Beer Talk
  • Website
  • Non-Beer Talk
  • Industry News
  • Beer Events
  • Beer and Food
  • BeerPal Polls
  • Unreplied
  • Popular All Time

JLOZIER
16057

JLOZIER
16057

JLOZIER
16057

Is this beer?

General Beer Discussion by JLOZIER

Last weekend I sampled a beer made from an ancient Egyptian recipe that Great Basin made in cross-promotion with some exhibit that the Nevada Natural History Museum's anniversary (I'm not sure if that is quite correct; maybe Slowrunner can clarify). I thought it would be some kind of Dogfish Head spit beer, but they used coriander for flavor (and not saliva) so I tried it. Anyway, this beer is made with a 50/50 split of roasted emmer and 2-row barley, yeast, and no hops. I didn't add it because a). I didn't know if it actually qualified as "beer" as this site defines it, and b). I had no idea what style it would fall into. What say you?[?]


13 years ago
# 6
# 6

FOAMDOME
18340

Spiced seems to make more sense to me, because of the coriander, than the nominal style (lager). Add it. Another site has it categorized as a Dortmunder / Helles. With zero hops, I don't get THAT choice at all.

13 years ago
# 7
# 7

CYRENAICA
447557

The DFH beer from Egypt used an ';ancient' wild yeast strain. The DFH 'spit' beer was Peruvian (and not something I'll knowingly ever try). Note to DFH, If you absolutely need to make a beer that uses amylase, there are several labs in the US that can make a synthetic version..........

13 years ago
# 8
# 8

FOAMDOME
18340

quote: Originally posted by cyrenaica
The DFH beer from Egypt used an ';ancient' wild yeast strain. The DFH 'spit' beer was Peruvian (and not something I'll knowingly ever try). Note to DFH, If you absolutely need to make a beer that uses amylase, there are several labs in the US that can make a synthetic version..........
Oh, good grief! It's not as if Sam spit in your beer just before you were going to take a sip. After the grain is milled by teeth and the starches broken down by enzymes in saliva, the corn slurry is baked at a temperature high enough to kill any germs. If the starches were not broken down to simpler sugars, there would be nothing for the wild yeast to play with, i.e., no beer.

13 years ago
# 9
# 9

Chicha! [img]http://ultimateears.com/uploads/assets/atw/roots-of-chicha-2.jpg[/img]

13 years ago
# 10
# 10

quote: Originally posted by FoamDome
quote: quote: Originally posted by cyrenaica
The DFH beer from Egypt used an ';ancient' wild yeast strain. The DFH 'spit' beer was Peruvian (and not something I'll knowingly ever try). Note to DFH, If you absolutely need to make a beer that uses amylase, there are several labs in the US that can make a synthetic version..........
Oh, good grief! It's not as if Sam spit in your beer just before you were going to take a sip. After the grain is milled by teeth and the starches broken down by enzymes in saliva, the corn slurry is baked at a temperature high enough to kill any germs. If the starches were not broken down to simpler sugars, there would be nothing for the wild yeast to play with, i.e., no beer.
I have the same issues, just knowing that turns me off. Same with Kopi Luwak coffee, knowing that the beans have passed through the intestinal tract of another animal.............not my cup of tea (or mug of coffee as the case may be). Sure, you have an issue of using a synthetic protein vs naturally occuring protein, but some bodily functions are best left to the individual and not shared with others. Beer made with natual saliva and coffee made from animal poop among them.

13 years ago
# 11
# 11

FOAMDOME
18340

quote: Originally posted by treborius
quote: quote: Originally posted by FoamDome
quote: quote: quote: Originally posted by cyrenaica
The DFH beer from Egypt used an ';ancient' wild yeast strain. The DFH 'spit' beer was Peruvian (and not something I'll knowingly ever try). Note to DFH, If you absolutely need to make a beer that uses amylase, there are several labs in the US that can make a synthetic version..........
Oh, good grief! It's not as if Sam spit in your beer just before you were going to take a sip. After the grain is milled by teeth and the starches broken down by enzymes in saliva, the corn slurry is baked at a temperature high enough to kill any germs. If the starches were not broken down to simpler sugars, there would be nothing for the wild yeast to play with, i.e., no beer.
I have the same issues, just knowing that turns me off. Same with Kopi Luwak coffee, knowing that the beans have passed through the intestinal tract of another animal.............not my cup of tea (or mug of coffee as the case may be). Sure, you have an issue of using a synthetic protein vs naturally occuring protein, but some bodily functions are best left to the individual and not shared with others. Beer made with natual saliva and coffee made from animal poop among them.
Point well-made. I first heard of cat poop coffee in the movie Bucket List. I thought it hysterical that the Jack Nicholaus character had know idea what he was drinking and apparently only liked it because it was expensive. If my point were valid, I should be equally likely to try the beer or the coffee. That's not true. I am more squeamish about the coffee.

13 years ago
# 12
# 12

FOAMDOME
18340

quote: Originally posted by bluesandbarbq
Chicha! [img]http://ultimateears.com/uploads/assets/atw/roots-of-chicha-2.jpg[/img]
Looks tasty, but... what is that froth floating on top? Ha!

13 years ago
# 13
# 13

Sorry I just stumbled onto this one, but I can't be of much help anyway. I haven't had much to do with Great Basin for months, unfortunately, due to crappy customer service. Been going to Silver Peak for the local fix, and will keep doing so. As far as the beer goes, spiced ale sounds right. Chica creeps me out a little, but I'll try it if I can. And for whatever reason, the weasel poo creeps me out less...and BG Brunch is one of my very favorite beers, so you squeemish folk are really missing out.

13 years ago
# 14
# 14

Lets face it we do eat hotdogs. LOL

13 years ago
# 15
# 15

KINGER
40797

KINGER
40797

As long as ciders and meads are allowed on these sites then that is clearly beer. With at least 50% barley malt anything is still beer in my book, this includes Braggot, Wheat Wine and anything else that is tasty.

13 years ago
Sign up to participate!