Categories

  • All Discussions
  • Hottest Topics
  • My Discussions
  • Specific Beers
  • Specific Brewers
  • General Beer Talk
  • Website
  • Non-Beer Talk
  • Industry News
  • Beer Events
  • Beer and Food
  • BeerPal Polls
  • Unreplied
  • Popular All Time

STALEYIV
23573

STALEYIV
23573

Samuel Adams Hefeweizen

General Beer Discussion by STALEYIV

Hey, have any of you guys tried this SA brew? I have not seen it yet but want to try it. How does it measure up? Also, how is the SA Scottish Ale, is it any good?


20 years ago
# 2
# 2

STALEYIV
23573

I can always count on Cottrell to not sugar-coat things when it comes to Sam Adams. However, I still want to try it; maybe the SA Hefeweizen would be better with a garnish of lemon.

20 years ago
# 3
# 3

BRETT
25065

BRETT
25065

The SA Hefe is sub par. It is not a 'bad' beer by any means, just truly unimpressive. The fact that the contents in the bottle do not reflect the style label on the outside of the bottle cost it a few points for my review, which was 2.9. 0.4 points higher than Cottrell.

20 years ago
# 4
# 4

In Reply To #1 For once Cotrell is correct! The stuff in made in yankeeland by one of the worst mid size breweries in the nation. Sham Adams is a fake and a fraud. With hefe, stick with the Krauts, they got it going on.

This message was edited by Brad Pear at 11/18/2004 10:30:57 PM.

20 years ago
# 5
# 5

Leave it up to me to disagree. I find the Sam Adams Hefe very refreshing and enjoyable. It is what it is however, a summery wheat beer, if you expect more, then you will be disappointed. I liked it, had it on a nice hot summer day. Actually, have you tried the SA Summer beer? May as well be the same thing. Refreshing wheat beer with lemon characteristics, and a small bite.

20 years ago
# 6
# 6

COTTRELL
19268

In Reply To #3 As a rule, I personally never add anything to a beer, with the exception of syrups to a Berliner. However, SA's Hefe would really benefit from that lemon. As it is, it's just a boring American Wheat. Don't get me wrong, I do like some of SA's beers, but some of the beers that they push the hardest are the worst of their line. They should really push the Scotch Ale, D-bock, or even the Cream Stout. Instead, I see subpar beers taking shelf space away from quality local beers from brewers that are struggling to make ends meet. Damn shame.

20 years ago
# 7
# 7

COTTRELL
19268

In Reply To #5 There are some good hefe's made in the U.S. too you know. Up here in "Yankeeland", Victory makes a Sunrise Weiss that can combat any German hefe that I've had so far (which, admittedly, isn't as many as I should have).

20 years ago
# 8
# 8

COTTRELL
19268

In Reply To #6 I prefer their summer ale to the hefewiezen. There's a bit of a lemony flavor in there as well as some yeasty flavors that the hefeweizen lacks. That said, both are mediocre at best, IMHO of course. :)

20 years ago
# 9
# 9

In Reply To #10 I thought they were very similar, although I do agree with you, the Summer ALe is slightly better. Both I found refreshing, and definitely got the job done on a hot summer day. They're not complex though, pretty basic American Wheats. I guess I don't mind that. I thought you didn't like their D-Bock? Too potent for me. The Scotch Ale was very solid, and their Cream stout was pretty good too. I really like their Boston Ale too and you don't see that nearly as much as their lager.

20 years ago
# 10
# 10

COTTRELL
19268

In Reply To #11 I don't like the d-bock fresh at all. It's just too sweet and boozy at that point. But hot damn is it a good beer after a year of aging. I plan on picking up a six pack as soon as I see it this year, just so I can age it. I don't mind waiting a year for a beer that good. You're right about the Boston Ale, it's a very nice English style session ale. I think it's probably their most under rated and over looked beer. I avoided it for a long time because I figured a pale ale from Sam Adams would be less than good, but after receiving a mixed pack from a friend and trying it, I now know better.

20 years ago
# 11
# 11

In Reply To #12 I don't know if I'd have the patience to wait out a beer for a year! Fortunately I can now get a sixer of the SA Boston Ale at a local store.

20 years ago
Sign up to participate!