Categories

  • All Discussions
  • Hottest Topics
  • My Discussions
  • Specific Beers
  • Specific Brewers
  • General Beer Talk
  • Website
  • Non-Beer Talk
  • Industry News
  • Beer Events
  • Beer and Food
  • BeerPal Polls
  • Unreplied
  • Popular All Time

FOAMDOME
18340

FOAMDOME
18340

Measures of Cost in Beer Reviews

Website Comments by FOAMDOME

Anyone else notice something not quite right about the cost part of the beer review screen? When asked to rate the cost of a beer compared to others in its style, the options range from: 1-Not worth it, to 5-Can't miss My Websight Comment for discussion is that the lables for the most and least expensive scores are poorly worded because they imply that expensive beers aren't worth the investment, or that inexpensive ones are always a good deal. I have no problems with the word lables associated with scores 2-4. Suggestion #2,473 is that we change the lables for the most and least expensive scores to "relatively expensive" and "relatively inexpensive" (not "cheap"--that's value-laden), respectively. Justification is that sometimes a beer is worth more than others in its style category. However, the score of "1" has a negative connotation. Likewise, a cheap price isn't always a good value, despite the positive connotation of a "5." Value is Quality per unit Price. Comment?


19 years ago
# 1
# 1

PKSMITH
7945

I somewhat disagree. I've tasted cheap beers that weren't worth the price (PBR? PBR anyone?) and $7.00 a bottle beers that were can't miss. I agree on the fact that some may simply say, without even a true review, that one bottle of beer costing, say, $7.00 is simply not worth the cost. Yes, cost is indicative of quality. Quality should be assigned based on the beer however, and not the cost. My favorite example of this is Southpaw Light. This is a beer I regularly get for less than $7.00 a half case, but is a nice tasting, high ABV (by macro standards) beer.

19 years ago
# 2
# 2

FLASHPRO
49720

Ah, don't worry about it. it's being tossed. Though I do agree the labeling is confusing. I never wanted to get very scientific about it for many reasons. Beer prices vary so much around the world and also depending on how you're buying it. The quantity or type of retailer (bar, wholesale, take-out, special order) makes it impossible to measure it numerically without bogging down the database with more info. So, because of the complications of purchase method, and subjectiveness of value, I'm not sure it's even worth having anymore. Personally, I've never, ever paid attention to a reviewer's cost assessment. On the other hand, sometimes I think it would be neat if you could simply enter the price and quantity of your purchase. Then you could add up how much you've spent :p. That would be frightingly interesting! It would be funny to see "$0.23/oz" next to a beer's rating.

This message was edited by Flashpro at 8/2/2004 9:41:14 AM.

19 years ago
Sign up to participate!